Contact: +1 (888) 605-1350
Choosing between Margaritaville Vacation Club – St. Thomas and Scrub Island Resort, Spa & Marina? This in-depth comparison breaks down location, vibe, rooms, food, nightlife, price & more so you can decide which resort fits your next getaway.
Best for travelers who want a laid-back Caribbean escape in the U.S. Virgin Islands with easy U.S. territory access, a relaxed island lifestyle vibe, and no passport required for American citizens.
Better for travelers who want a private island resort experience in the British Virgin Islands with a full-service marina, secluded beaches, and a more remote Caribbean setting.
If you want a relaxed Caribbean getaway with easy U.S. territory access and a casual island lifestyle atmosphere, Margaritaville Vacation Club - St. Thomas is typically the better pick—especially for travelers who value no passport requirements (for U.S. citizens), familiar conveniences, and a laid-back vibe.
If your priority is a private island experience with a marina-focused setting, Scrub Island Resort, Spa & Marina usually comes out ahead—particularly for travelers who want a more secluded escape, boating access, and the British Virgin Islands experience.
Bottom line: choose Margaritaville St. Thomas for accessible Caribbean relaxation in the U.S. Virgin Islands, and choose Scrub Island for a private island resort with marina amenities in the BVI.
| Category | Margaritaville Vacation Club - St. Thomas | Scrub Island Resort, Spa & Marina |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Vibe |
Laid-back island lifestyle resort in the U.S. Virgin Islands with a relaxed Caribbean atmosphere and casual, easygoing energy.
Best for Easy Access
|
Private island marina resort in the British Virgin Islands with a more secluded, nautical-focused Caribbean experience.
Best for Seclusion
|
| Location | Located in St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands—a U.S. territory with no passport required for American citizens and easy flight access. | Located on a private island in the British Virgin Islands, accessible by boat or ferry, offering a more remote Caribbean setting. |
| Accommodations | Comfortable accommodations with Caribbean views, designed for relaxed island stays with a casual resort atmosphere. | Resort accommodations on a private island with marina views, suited for travelers seeking a more exclusive island setting. |
| Dining | On-site dining with a casual island vibe, featuring Caribbean-inspired cuisine and laid-back waterfront atmosphere. | Resort dining options with waterfront and marina views, offering Caribbean and international cuisine in a more secluded setting. |
| Pool & Beach | Resort pool and access to St. Thomas beaches, with the island's well-known Caribbean waters and beach experiences nearby. | Private island beaches and resort pools with a more secluded shoreline experience in the British Virgin Islands. |
| Marina & Boating | Water activities and excursions available from St. Thomas, a popular Caribbean departure point for island-hopping. | Full-service marina on-site, making it a strong choice for boaters and travelers who want marina-based Caribbean access. |
| Travel Logistics | Direct flights to St. Thomas from major U.S. cities; no passport required for U.S. citizens; U.S. currency accepted. | Requires travel to the British Virgin Islands with boat or ferry transfer to the private island; passport required for U.S. citizens. |
Accommodations at Margaritaville Vacation Club - St. Thomas are designed for relaxed Caribbean stays with a casual island atmosphere and views of the surrounding U.S. Virgin Islands waters.
Margaritaville St. Thomas is the better pick if you want accessible Caribbean comfort without the complexity of international travel.
Scrub Island Resort, Spa & Marina offers private island accommodations with marina views and a more secluded Caribbean resort experience in the British Virgin Islands.
If you want a private island experience with a full-service marina, Scrub Island offers the more secluded setting.
Dining at Margaritaville Vacation Club - St. Thomas embraces the casual island lifestyle with Caribbean-inspired cuisine and a laid-back waterfront atmosphere.
Expect:
Scrub Island Resort, Spa & Marina offers resort dining on a private island with waterfront and marina views in a more secluded British Virgin Islands setting.
If marina-side dining and a private island setting matter most, Scrub Island offers the more exclusive atmosphere.
Margaritaville Vacation Club - St. Thomas features a resort pool setting with access to the well-known beaches of St. Thomas and surrounding Caribbean waters.
Scrub Island Resort, Spa & Marina offers private island beaches with a more secluded shoreline experience and resort pools in the British Virgin Islands.
If private beaches and a secluded island shoreline are priorities, Scrub Island offers the more exclusive beach experience.
Margaritaville Vacation Club - St. Thomas provides access to water activities and excursions from St. Thomas, a popular Caribbean hub for island-hopping and exploration.
Scrub Island Resort, Spa & Marina features a full-service marina, making it an attractive choice for boaters and travelers who want marina-based Caribbean access.
If a full-service marina and boating access are important, Scrub Island is the stronger fit for nautical travelers.
Margaritaville Vacation Club - St. Thomas offers straightforward travel logistics as a U.S. territory destination with direct flights and familiar conveniences.
Scrub Island Resort, Spa & Marina requires travel to the British Virgin Islands with boat or ferry transfer to the private island—a more adventurous arrival experience.
Choose Margaritaville St. Thomas if you want easy U.S. territory access, no passport hassles, and a laid-back Caribbean escape with direct flights from major cities.
Scrub Island is the better pick for boaters and sailing enthusiasts who want a full-service marina and nautical Caribbean lifestyle.
For casual Caribbean vibes and island lifestyle relaxation, Margaritaville St. Thomas delivers the laid-back atmosphere with easy conveniences.
If you want a private island escape with secluded beaches and a more remote Caribbean experience, Scrub Island offers the exclusive setting.
Questions? Contact Us!
Explore more helpful planning guides and insider articles for Margaritaville Vacation Club - St. Thomas:
