Contact: +1 (888) 605-1350
Choosing between Margaritaville Vacation Club – St. Thomas and The Aerial, BVI? This in-depth comparison breaks down location, vibe, rooms, food, nightlife, price & more so you can decide which resort is the best fit.
Best for travelers who want a laid-back Caribbean resort experience in St. Thomas with easy U.S. territory access, no passport required for American citizens, and that signature island-casual Margaritaville atmosphere.
Better for travelers seeking an exclusive private island escape in the British Virgin Islands with ultra-luxury accommodations, secluded settings, and a more remote Caribbean experience.
If you want a relaxed Caribbean resort with easy access from the U.S. mainland and that signature island-casual vibe, Margaritaville Vacation Club - St. Thomas is typically the better pick—especially for travelers who value convenient flights, no passport requirements for U.S. citizens, and a laid-back atmosphere.
If your priority is an ultra-exclusive private island experience in a more remote Caribbean setting, The Aerial, BVI usually comes out ahead—particularly for travelers who want maximum seclusion, luxury accommodations, and a British Virgin Islands escape.
Bottom line: choose Margaritaville Vacation Club - St. Thomas for accessible island living with familiar comforts in the U.S. Virgin Islands, and choose The Aerial, BVI for a secluded ultra-luxury private island retreat.
| Category | Margaritaville Vacation Club - St. Thomas | The Aerial, BVI |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Vibe |
Laid-back island resort with a casual Caribbean atmosphere, poolside relaxation, and that signature Margaritaville lifestyle in the U.S. Virgin Islands.
Best for Easy Access
|
Ultra-exclusive private island resort with secluded luxury, pristine settings, and a remote British Virgin Islands experience.
Best for Seclusion
|
| Location | In St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands—a U.S. territory with direct flights from many mainland cities and no passport required for American citizens. | In the British Virgin Islands, requiring international travel and typically additional transport to reach the private island setting. |
| Accommodations | Comfortable resort accommodations designed for relaxation, with Caribbean views and island-style amenities. | Ultra-luxury private accommodations with high-end finishes and an exclusive, secluded atmosphere. |
| Dining | On-site dining with Caribbean flavors and that casual Margaritaville approach to island cuisine and tropical drinks. | Upscale private dining experiences with a focus on exclusivity and personalized service. |
| Pool & Beach | Resort pool with poolside bar and access to St. Thomas beaches—great for a relaxed Caribbean day. | Private beach access and secluded waterfront settings typical of a private island resort. |
| Activities | Easy access to St. Thomas attractions, water sports, and island exploration with convenient proximity to Charlotte Amalie. | Exclusive private island activities focused on seclusion, water-based experiences, and personalized adventures. |
| Price & Value | Best value for travelers who want Caribbean relaxation with familiar comforts and easy U.S. territory access. | Best value for travelers seeking an ultra-luxury private island experience where exclusivity is the priority. |
Accommodations at Margaritaville Vacation Club - St. Thomas are comfortable, island-casual, and designed for relaxation, with Caribbean views and amenities that support the laid-back Margaritaville lifestyle.
Margaritaville is the better pick if you want accessible island comfort without the complexity of international travel to a remote private island.
The Aerial, BVI delivers an ultra-luxury private island experience with exclusive accommodations, secluded settings, and high-end finishes throughout.
If you want an exclusive private island escape with ultra-luxury accommodations, The Aerial, BVI is the stronger fit.
Dining at Margaritaville Vacation Club - St. Thomas embraces the casual island lifestyle, with Caribbean-inspired cuisine, tropical drinks, and that signature laid-back Margaritaville approach.
Expect:
The Aerial, BVI typically offers upscale private dining with personalized service and exclusive culinary experiences befitting a private island resort.
If exclusive private dining and personalized culinary service matter most, The Aerial, BVI is usually the better match.
Margaritaville Vacation Club - St. Thomas features a resort pool with poolside bar and access to St. Thomas beaches, perfect for a relaxed Caribbean day with island convenience.
The Aerial, BVI offers private beach access and secluded waterfront settings typical of an exclusive private island resort in the British Virgin Islands.
If you want a private beach experience with maximum seclusion, The Aerial, BVI usually wins.
Margaritaville Vacation Club - St. Thomas offers easy access to St. Thomas attractions, water sports, shopping in Charlotte Amalie, and island exploration—all with U.S. territory convenience.
The Aerial, BVI focuses on exclusive private island activities, with water-based experiences and personalized adventures in a secluded British Virgin Islands setting.
If your goal is seclusion and exclusive experiences rather than island exploration, The Aerial, BVI is the stronger fit.
Margaritaville Vacation Club - St. Thomas offers the most value when you want Caribbean relaxation with easy access, familiar comforts, and U.S. territory convenience.
The Aerial, BVI is the better value if your priorities are ultra-luxury exclusivity, private island seclusion, and a remote Caribbean escape.
Choose Margaritaville if you want easy Caribbean access with direct U.S. flights, no passport required for Americans, and laid-back island vibes.
The Aerial is the better pick for ultra-exclusive private island luxury with maximum seclusion in the British Virgin Islands.
For travelers who want to explore St. Thomas, enjoy local attractions, and have easy access to Charlotte Amalie, Margaritaville offers the better base.
If you want the ultimate private island experience with exclusive accommodations and personalized luxury, The Aerial, BVI delivers.
Questions? Contact Us!
Explore more helpful planning guides and insider articles for Margaritaville Vacation Club - St. Thomas:
